args-framework issueshttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues2020-03-02T10:41:22Zhttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/55Aspect space view on mobile2020-03-02T10:41:22ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deAspect space view on mobileThe font size should probably be increased on smaller displays. Maybe also other adjustments are needed?The font size should probably be increased on smaller displays. Maybe also other adjustments are needed?Dora KieselDora Kieselhttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/53Aspect space view: loading indicator on argument list2020-03-02T10:42:04ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deAspect space view: loading indicator on argument listShow a loading indicator upon selection until the result list is updatedShow a loading indicator upon selection until the result list is updatedDora KieselDora Kieselhttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/51Aspect space view: on hover on point2020-03-02T10:41:52ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deAspect space view: on hover on pointOn hovering over a point or after selecting a point, it might be good to illustrate how the point has been positioned:
- As sum of normalized dimension vectors
- As center of weighted polygon
- As center in a spring system with spr...On hovering over a point or after selecting a point, it might be good to illustrate how the point has been positioned:
- As sum of normalized dimension vectors
- As center of weighted polygon
- As center in a spring system with springs attached to dimension squaresDora KieselDora Kieselhttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/50Aspect space view: large dimension squares overlap with argument points2020-03-02T10:42:23ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deAspect space view: large dimension squares overlap with argument pointsIf an argument has only one aspect, it is not visible in the aspect space view.If an argument has only one aspect, it is not visible in the aspect space view.Dora KieselDora Kieselhttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/36Use DirichletLM for retrieval2021-05-08T07:04:17ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deUse DirichletLM for retrievalBased on results in https://webis.de/publications.html#filter:Assessing%20Argument%20Relevance
Not sure if we need to go Terrier for that? Anserini might also be an option if we want to stay with Lucene/Elastic (have not checked whether...Based on results in https://webis.de/publications.html#filter:Assessing%20Argument%20Relevance
Not sure if we need to go Terrier for that? Anserini might also be an option if we want to stay with Lucene/Elastic (have not checked whether they support it). I have not used Terrier so far.
Switching out Lucene would be a good test to see how general the framework is ;)
(in theory it should work without much problems...)Alexander BondarenkoAlexander Bondarenkohttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/32Reporting problems with arguments2021-03-03T08:14:06ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deReporting problems with argumentsThere should be an option to allow users of args.me to report back when they see "strange" or "bad" arguments.
Things we might want to be reported:
- Spam arguments: #31, #9
- Not helpful arguments: #25
- Formatting problems: #2...There should be an option to allow users of args.me to report back when they see "strange" or "bad" arguments.
Things we might want to be reported:
- Spam arguments: #31, #9
- Not helpful arguments: #25
- Formatting problems: #22, #8
- Racist/Sexists/... arguments
- ...?
What other services face similar problems? What are their interfaces?
Finding a balance between expressiveness of the labels and simplicity of the reporting interface will be essential.
In a first step, we might just want to collect such reports, review them, and have some functionality to blacklist the arguments if we deem appropriate.
A second step (not part of this issue) would be to automate this process.Johannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.dehttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/28Nonsense arguments2020-04-19T14:01:49ZMartin Potthastmartin.potthast@uni-weimar.deNonsense argumentsSee https://args2.webis.de/search.html?query=test
Those should be removed from the data.See https://args2.webis.de/search.html?query=test
Those should be removed from the data.https://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/14Debate.org same discussions with same instigator2020-03-02T10:47:42ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deDebate.org same discussions with same instigatorSome debaters start the same discussion with other people. This leads to a higher count of the conclusion than appropriate, which can cause problems, for example in #6.
For example suggested conclusion which is long and is very specific...Some debaters start the same discussion with other people. This leads to a higher count of the conclusion than appropriate, which can cause problems, for example in #6.
For example suggested conclusion which is long and is very specific: war game scenario russia versus chosen nation have debates (2-3) from the same debater.https://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/6Query interpretation: Matching with indexed conclusions2020-03-02T10:44:10ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deQuery interpretation: Matching with indexed conclusionsCopied from https://git.webis.de/webisstud/wstud-argument-search-engine-ss18/issues/5
The query interpretation based on a matching with indexed conclusions, developed in a student project in Weimar, is not integrated into args.me yet.Copied from https://git.webis.de/webisstud/wstud-argument-search-engine-ss18/issues/5
The query interpretation based on a matching with indexed conclusions, developed in a student project in Weimar, is not integrated into args.me yet.Johannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.dehttps://git.webis.de/code-research/arguana/args/args-framework/-/issues/5Counterarguments2020-03-02T10:40:01ZJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deCounterargumentsCopied from https://git.webis.de/webisstud/wstud-argument-search-engine-ss18/issues/7
The retrieval of counterarguments, developed in the ACL 2018 paper and then implemented by Philipp Rudloff in his bachelor's thesis, is not integrated...Copied from https://git.webis.de/webisstud/wstud-argument-search-engine-ss18/issues/7
The retrieval of counterarguments, developed in the ACL 2018 paper and then implemented by Philipp Rudloff in his bachelor's thesis, is not integrated yet.
The counterargument candidates should be found offline and indexed, and then displayed in the user interface.Johannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.deJohannes Kieseljohannes.kiesel@uni-weimar.de